Finally, "a glimmer of closure" as personal items found on Colorado mountain where hiker disappeared 19 years ago

Hikers descent Mount of the Holy Cross
Michelle Vanek’s disappearance in 2005 sparked a large-scale search effort (Image credit: Rich Crowder)

Nearly two decades after a hiker disappeared on one of Colorado's highest peaks, a discovery may help bring some closure to this long-running mystery.

In a Facebook post on Saturday, Eagle County Sheriff's Office reported that Vail Mountain Rescue Group has found personal items that "closely resemble" those of missing hiker Michelle Vanek on Mount of the Holy Cross, a peak in the Sawatch Range south of Vail.

"This discovery marks a milestone in the long search for Michelle," writes the ECSO.

"We are filled with hope as a recent discovery in the area may finally bring her family, friends, and the entire community the closure they have long sought."

Vanek's case has become notorious in the hiking community after the 34-year-old mother of four disappeared while hiking the 14,011-foot peak on September 24, 2005. Vanek had set off with a friend to summit what was to be her first Colorado 14er – a peak over 14,000 ft tall – but she never made it to the top.

Things reportedly got off on the wrong foot when the pair could not find the correct trailhead, then set off late on the wrong trail, which took them on a much longer and more difficult route than planned. Just a few hundred yards from the summit, Vanek's partner says she told him she was unable to continue. She had run out of water, and it is thought she was likely suffering from altitude sickness and was poorly dressed for high altitude hiking.

She told her partner to continue, and he directed her to begin her descent, telling her he would catch up with her on the way down. That was the last time anybody ever saw Vanek.

Mountain landscape in the Holy Cross Wilderness, Colorado

Vanek's disappearance prompted a massive search of the boulder field where she was last seen – the biggest in the state's history (Image credit: Patrick Lienin)

Vanek's disappearance prompted a massive search of the boulder field where she was last seen – the biggest in the state's history – but efforts were fruitless. Search efforts were called off with the arrival of snow, but the ECSO reports that the case has always remained important to them.

"Sheriff James Van Beek has a search grid map from that very search hanging on his office wall, placed there by his predecessor as a constant reminder of a case unresolved and a family left incomplete."

No trace of the woman has ever been found until last year, when we reported that a Sorel Asystec hiking boot found below Angelica Couloir had been forensically confirmed to belong to Vanek.

The ECSO reports that due to the sensitive nature of the case and the need for further searches, they are not revealing the exact location of the discovery, which they describe as a "milestone" in the case.

14er safety

Hiking or climbing a mountain over 4,900 feet high is officially classified as high altitude hiking and it requires a different skill set (and equipment) from hiking at lower levels.

Vanek's case highlights the importance of hiking safety, and it's a good reminder to follow certain principles if you're planning to venture into higher elevations:

It’s often easier to get lost on a 14er than on a trail through the woods. Though treeline varies from one region to another, any 14er is bound to take you up above it. Once you leave the trees, any soft, well-maintained path tends to give way to boulder fields where you have to rely on rock cairns to navigate. This is tricky and a bit disorienting, and many unsuspecting hikers have spent an unplanned night out in the cold as a result. Read more in our article on hiking 14ers in Colorado.

Julia Clarke

Julia Clarke is a staff writer for Advnture.com and the author of the book Restorative Yoga for Beginners. She loves to explore mountains on foot, bike, skis and belay and then recover on the the yoga mat. Julia graduated with a degree in journalism in 2004 and spent eight years working as a radio presenter in Kansas City, Vermont, Boston and New York City before discovering the joys of the Rocky Mountains. She then detoured west to Colorado and enjoyed 11 years teaching yoga in Vail before returning to her hometown of Glasgow, Scotland in 2020 to focus on family and writing.